AI Overviews: What’s Happening to Organic Traffic on Your Website?

AI Overviews: What’s Happening to Organic Traffic on Your Website?
7:35

Every business owner or marketer knows the importance of organic traffic. But have you noticed a dip lately? You’re not alone. AI-driven algorithms are transforming how search engines work, fundamentally shifting how websites draw in traffic. For local businesses relying on consistent website visits, this change could make or break their digital presence.

This blog explores how artificial intelligence (AI) in search engines impacts organic traffic, the latest trends, and actionable strategies to help businesses and SEO professionals adapt to this new landscape.

Small Business Guide to Digital Advertising CTA

How AI is Revolutionizing Search Engines

Search engines are no longer simple tools for matching keywords to web pages. Instead, they’ve evolved into highly intelligent platforms, leveraging the power of AI to better understand user intent and provide more relevant results. Let's explore some key developments:

Google’s AI-Driven Algorithms

  • BERT (Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers) and RankBrain enable Google to grasp the context behind search queries, not just the keywords.
  • MUM (Multitask Unified Model) is setting the stage for answering complex queries by analyzing data across multiple formats (text, images, videos) in multiple languages.
  • The goal? Better matching of content to user questions—but this means local businesses must fine-tune their content like never before. Generic posts won’t cut it anymore!

Bing’s Integration with ChatGPT

  • Bing's partnership with ChatGPT allows users to experience conversational search, receiving rich, AI-generated answers.
  • This development pushes businesses to align their strategies with how AI models process content, making it critical to provide detailed yet concise information on your site.

AI-Generated Search Results Driving Change

Generative AI tools like ChatGPT and Google’s Bard have added a new layer to search results. While these tools make it easier for users to find answers directly on the search page, fewer users are clicking on traditional organic links. This trend, called “zero-click searches,” has ramped up competition for visibility.

What Does an AI Overview Result Look Like?

The graphic below highlights the main elements you’ll see after performing a search. These are often content-focused queries, typically phrased as simple questions or ranked lists, using terms like “best,” “top,” or “cheapest.”

When you search for something like "Why is marketing important?", the AI Overview pulls together information from across the web to give you a summarized answer. Next to the answer, you'll see "preview links" on the right side of the page, which act as the AI's way of citing its sources. Below the overview, the usual organic search results appear. However, on most screens, only one or two results are visible without scrolling. This limits organic traffic, as many users get the information they need directly from the AI Overview without clicking through to a website.

Trends Impacting Organic Traffic Today

The Decline in Click-Through Rates

Generative AI-driven snippets are increasingly detailed, grabbing attention without requiring users to explore further. This means fewer clicks for websites—even if they rank high.

Content Quality is King (Again)

AI’s ability to assess the quality and relevance of content is now sharper than ever. Search engines no longer reward keyword-stuffed content. Instead, they prioritize:

  • Depth of research
  • Readability
  • User experience

If your content doesn't add value, it risks being overlooked by both search engines and users.

The Rise of Zero-Click Searches

Zero-click searches currently account for over 60% of all Google searches. These occur when users find their answers directly on the results page via summaries, maps, or quick facts—rather than clicking through to a site. For example:

  • Featured Snippets display bite-sized information pulled directly from a website.
  • Local Packs show essential business details (e.g., address, phone number) without requiring extra clicks.

This makes standing out more challenging... but not impossible.

Steps for Local Businesses to Thrive in the AI Era

Yes, AI has rewritten the rules of digital marketing. But there are effective strategies you can apply to thrive in this fast-changing environment.

1. Optimize for Local Search and Voice Search

  • Use Schema Markup to provide search engines with structured data like operating hours, reviews, and events. Tools like Google’s Structured Data Markup Helper can assist.
  • Many searches now begin with voice assistants (e.g., “Where’s the nearest coffee shop?”). Ensure your content aligns with conversational phrases.

2. Focus on User Experience

When ranking pages, AI-driven algorithms prioritize UX factors such as:

  • Fast Loading Times: Check your site speed using tools like Google PageSpeed Insights.
  • Mobile Optimization: More than half of web traffic comes from mobile devices. Ensure seamless navigation on smaller screens.
  • Clear Navigation: Make it easy for visitors to find what they need quickly!

3. Diversify Your Content Strategy

Relying solely on blog posts won’t cut it anymore. Diversify with:

  • Video Content: Platforms like YouTube (second only to Google in search) can drive traffic effectively using video content.
  • Infographics: Visually appealing content is highly shareable and impactful.
  • Social Media Posts: Don’t silo off your content—direct followers from platforms like Instagram to your site.

4. Build Brand Authority

Search engines favor trustworthy brands, particularly in local search results. Strengthen your authority:

  • Garner reviews on platforms like Google My Business.
  • Collaborate with reputable websites for backlinks.
  • Publish high-quality, consistent content on your blog.

Preparing for the Future of AI and Organic Traffic

The only predictable thing about AI is its continuous evolution. Here are some trends to monitor and prepare for:

AI-Generated Content Will Increase Competition

Businesses are leveraging AI tools like Jasper and ChatGPT to produce content faster. To stand out, ensure your content remains authentic and tailored to your target audience.

Search Intent Will Become More Sophisticated

The focus will shift further toward voice searches, hyper-local queries, and detailed comparison searches requiring highly specific content.

Personalization Will Drive Engagement

AI-powered personalization tools could make content that speaks directly to user needs vital for sustained traffic.

Video and Interactive Content Will Dominate

Interactive formats like quizzes, DIY demos, or video walkthroughs will gain heavier traction as users demand more engaging experiences.

Staying Proactive in a Changing SEO LandscapeSubscribe-to-the-Missouri-Marketing-Resource-blog-square

AI is here to stay, but its impact on organic traffic doesn’t have to feel dire. By staying informed, adapting your strategies, and emphasizing quality over quantity, your website can continue to perform and grow.

Whether you're a local business or an SEO professional, a thorough strategy incorporating local optimization, content diversity, and authentic brand authority will help you thrive—even amidst technological disruption.

Remember, it’s not enough to keep pace with AI updates. You need to stay ahead of them. By implementing these strategies, you’ll position your website as a trusted, visible resource for your users—no matter where the AI-driven search landscape leads.

Back to Blog

Related Articles

WOW! I Didn't Know Zimmer Communications Does All That!

Originally published 12/7/22. Updated 2/17/25. At Zimmer Communications, our mission since we...

Why Mobile Optimization Should Be a Priority in Your Digital Strategy

Mobile devices have transformed the way we live, shop, and interact with the digital world. With...

10 Reasons Why Magazine Advertising Is Relevant

Amidst the digital marketing boom, where every click and scroll is laced with brand messages,...